Opinion / discussion: ~4-minute take on Federal’s then-new ammo subscription service (upload Dec 2021). This is a market/pricing commentary from that moment — not a multi-month SlavGuns T&E, not a Short, and not a current price check. Subscription terms, street prices, and whether the program still exists have almost certainly moved — verify anything live before you sign a contract or stockpile.
Squat Squad — Federal dropped an ammo subscription, and the pitch sounded slick: five boxes a month, shipping included, priority fulfillment, pick your flavor. Cool concept. Then I ran the numbers. Here’s the honest “deal or money grab?” breakdown from that Dec 2021 tape.
Gear I actually use: SlavGuns Amazon. Precision accessories: Anarchy Outdoors (code SlavGuns on Anarchy-manufactured items). Support the channel: join on YouTube.
What Federal was selling
Vista Outdoor (Federal’s parent at the time) had been talking consumer-direct for a while. The launch offer: five boxes per month of Federal American Eagle (“red box”) in 9mm, .40 S&W, or .45 ACP — 50-round boxes, so 250 rounds/month — with a 12-month commitment, shipping included, and priority handling over standard orders. Cell-phone-contract vibes. The idea itself? Fine. Knowing ammo is coming every month helps the shooter; predictable demand helps the manufacturer plan. Concept: good. Execution at those prices: not so much.
The monthly sticker (as taped, late 2021)
As published on the tape:
- 9mm — about $139.99/month (~$28/box)
- .40 S&W — about $151.99/month (~$30.40/box)
- .45 ACP — about $169.99/month (~$34/box)
That’s before tax. At the same moment you could still find comparable brass-cased range ammo roughly in the $18–$25/box lane — and aluminum-case 9mm cheaper than that if you weren’t picky. So the subscription wasn’t “lock in a deal.” It was locking in above-market.
Why the terms made it worse
Two gotchas stacked on the price:
- One-year commitment at that locked rate — and the published terms didn’t drop your subscription price if street ammo got cheaper.
- Early exit fee around $300 if you wanted out. (Yes, sarcasm was intentional on the tape.)
Locking a low price for a year can make sense. Locking a high price while ammo was still drifting back toward normal — I floated roughly ~$10/box 9mm, $12–13 .40, $15–20 .45 as a healthier “normal” then — means you overpay for twelve months with no downside protection.
What I’d do instead (opinion, then and now)
Unless you’re desperate and swimming in cash, there’s no logical reason to use a subscription at those numbers when equivalent quality ammo was available for roughly half with zero contract. Worried about the next supply shock? Stock up when prices are sane, and/or put money into a reloading press and some education — on the tape I noted you can load a box of 9mm for around $5 yourself (lower if you cast your own lead). And for the record: not sponsored by Federal.
Honest caveats
This is a ~4-minute opinion piece from Dec 2021, not me auditing Federal’s current storefront or chronographing American Eagle lots. Programs get renamed, repriced, or killed. Street ammo and online prices move weekly. Treat every dollar figure and “terms and conditions” line as historical as taped — check what’s live today before you click “subscribe.”
Bottom line
Great concept, bad price lock. If you want the full rant — monthly costs, the exit fee, and why stockpiling / reloading beat that contract at the time — watch the video. Shop today’s market for what you actually need; don’t plan a year of ammo off a four-year-old subscription pitch.
More gear I use: SlavGuns Amazon. Precision accessories: Anarchy Outdoors (code SlavGuns on Anarchy-manufactured items). Want the longer behind-the-scenes stuff? Join the channel.
Keep squatting.
Would you ever lock a year of ammo at a premium, or is stockpile + reload still the move?
Some links are affiliates. Purchases may support the channel at no extra cost to you. Always follow federal, state, and local law. Firearms, ammo, and suppressors ship to eligible buyers only.
Comment here